In his opinion, the judge shot down the jail's argument that male officers simply looked away, saying it would do "little, for most female inmates, to diminish the sense of embarrassment, humiliation, and vulnerability that she must inevitably feel. I do believe that if you are arrested for a minor charge you shouldn't be strip searched but patted down. During her monthlong stay at Wayne County Jail in October and November of , though, Sumpter "had just no idea what should or shouldn't be happening in jail," Dezsi says. In dissent, Justice Stephen Breyer said it was unreasonable to subject possibly innocent people to humiliating searches, particularly when they are not suspected of a serious crime. This is where Briana Fitzgibbons saw nude dancing and sex acts take place — on the top floor of a self-park garage across from the Metropolitan Correctional Center. Powered by Livefyre The opinions expressed in reader comments are those of the author only, and do not reflect the opinions of The Seattle Times.
United States Currier v. United States Chavez-Meza v. This coming Supreme Court Term, in the case of Florence v. More from these topics: In summary, strip searches may not be done during the booking process unless there is reasonable suspicion to believe that the particular suspect is concealing weapons or contraband. Whatever happened about morals, values, and law and order for the betterment of society??? Does the Constitution extend any protection for privacy to the people who reside in a detention facility?
Supreme Court OKs Strip Searches For Minor Offenses : NPR
Yes, they should be padded down, but they shouldn't be forced to strip completely naked in a cold room with a clothed officer invading their personal privacy making them pose in sexual degrading manners. And though the county produced schedules that show a "number of men that were assigned to work in the women's units," Dezsi says their response was that the men are only in place for "exigent circumstances," meaning if there was an emergency. Arts and Culture Arts and Culture Home. I disagree with the article on the Bell v. According to the article, Judge Thomas Hardiman said: Whether it be on a minor charge or a major charge, they may present a threat to society and it's the guard's duty to prevent the smuggle of weapons or drugs into their facility.
Because the votes of Alito and Roberts were necessary to make up the majority, it might well be that the Alito opinion will serve as the controlling opinion on that point. Strip Searches By Jack Ryan In the course of an arrest, law enforcement personnel are often called upon to conduct a strip search of a person. But the trooper said there was nothing he could do. A young man I was aware of was caught masturbating simply by being spotted through the observation window in his cell door. Thus, policy and practice must require individualized reasonable suspicion for strip searches of those persons who will be placed in a safety-cell. Stitt Virginia Uranium, Inc. Current Wisconsin law allows jailors to conduct strip searches if an inmate has been arrested for a felony or a number of different misdemeanors.